03:52.6
Ito, ito, guys. Things are getting serious.
03:54.9
Things are moving very, very fast, guys.
03:57.0
So after, ito, matagal na
03:59.1
diskusyon dito sa
04:06.6
guess na baka si Llamas
04:08.8
nandun na sa kabilang ngayon.
04:10.6
Parang medyo alam ko na yung algorithm
04:12.6
ng ngayon. Anyway,
04:17.0
ito, guys, because now you have
04:18.6
no less than the president himself
04:20.3
putting essentially the imprimatur, no?
04:22.6
The presidential imprimatur
04:25.4
chacha. At meron na silang
04:28.5
time frame. So isabay na daw
04:30.4
sa midterm elections next year
04:32.2
ang itong charter change. Of course,
04:34.7
not charter change yet. It's gonna be a plebiscite.
04:38.4
boboto ang mga taong bayan whether
04:40.3
pwede tayo magkaroon ng constitutional
04:42.3
change. So mukhang yun ang
04:43.9
approach nila, guys. So things
04:46.4
are getting serious na. So mukhang hindi lang
04:48.5
ito ay position na isang
04:50.2
faction lang. Hindi lang ito ay
04:52.2
hanash lang ng mga iba dyan sa kongreso
04:54.0
or senado. Mukhang mga kameta
04:56.2
ito ay talaga may presidential imprimatur na.
04:58.1
So let's discuss that. One thing
05:00.3
that is very important here is
05:01.6
surprise, surprise, si Digong
05:04.1
ngayon ay nag-change tone ulit. Yun ang
05:06.1
sinasabi ko parate. Kaya doon ako
05:08.9
minamahal natin ka-host na si
05:11.9
Ronald kasi last year
05:14.1
pa rin sinabi na ito na talaga, this is it.
05:16.3
Sabi ko hindi ito, this is it. Kasi
05:17.8
maglalaro talaga yung mga Dutertes
05:20.1
and Marqueses eh. Because both of them are trying
05:22.2
to avoid the D-Day situation
05:23.7
at si Digong, as much
05:26.2
as nagwawala siya, minsan nag-adjust
05:28.3
din siya, nagta-tactical retreat siya. So nagkaroon
05:30.2
ng tactical retreat din si Digong. So ngayon
05:32.2
sabi ni Digong, okay din siya
05:34.3
sa itong mga constitutional amendments
05:36.4
pero meron siyang
05:38.2
caveat, huwag sana
05:40.1
galawin yung presidential term limits
05:42.5
dahil of course, iniisip niya
05:44.3
yung kalagayan ng
05:46.1
kanyang anak, diba, na seen as
05:48.0
one of the frontrunners. Let's be very clear,
05:50.1
hindi na po frontrunner si
05:52.2
Tara. Hindi na siya the frontrunner.
05:54.7
One of the frontrunner na siya.
05:56.9
Because katulad ng sinabi natin,
05:58.4
may isang senador dyan
05:59.4
na mukhang siya na yung nagna-number one
06:02.3
ngayon dun sa mga survey agencies. Now ito yung
06:04.1
mga unpublished dahil ito yung mga commissioned.
06:06.7
So mukhang yung nag-commissioned,
06:08.1
parang gets ko sino nag-commissioned
06:10.3
kaya ay i-release to kasi hindi na siya number one.
06:12.4
But mahabang usapan na to. Pero
06:14.1
kami naman kasi may access kami
06:16.0
sa mga even non-commissioned
06:18.2
or at least we can confirm the data.
06:20.3
So sa pagkalam natin, hindi na
06:23.2
frontrunner. Wait lang,
06:26.2
na-distract ako sa Philippine Airlines.
06:28.0
Okay, pag-usapan natin yan. By the way, guys,
06:30.9
pasensya na dun sa
06:32.0
audio problems kaapon and all
06:40.0
nasaan na yung na-scotch tape
06:42.5
scotch tape ko na?
06:44.3
Gumagana na mga kanina. Check-check ko
06:46.2
yung earphones. Gumagana
06:48.4
naman yung scotch tape, scotch tape na yan.
06:50.1
So baka naman ang problema dito mga
06:52.2
guys, hindi itong, baka ang problema yung
06:54.1
phone ko. Baka luma na kasi itong phone na
06:56.0
ginagamit natin isa. Kasi syempre yung medyo
06:57.9
mas maganda natin phone, ginagamit natin dun sa
07:04.5
O baka magmagawa yung mga
07:06.0
platforms natin. So ayan na.
07:08.4
Baka kailangan natin kumuka ng bagong
07:10.0
phone. O baka naman, baka naman
07:12.2
malapit pa naman birthday
07:14.2
natin. Yan naman, nagparinig.
07:17.9
Hindi, guys, pero kung may recommendation kayo
07:20.2
kasi actually may mga, oh, nagjet
07:22.2
lag din yung phone ko. Kasi yung
07:24.2
nasa scotch tape ko na na-earphones.
07:26.6
Hindi ko alam. Mukhang
07:28.0
gumagana naman. Nag-scotch tape ulit
07:30.2
ako kanina. Ma, nasan yung
07:31.8
na-scotch tape ko kanina?
07:38.0
Yes, wala namang tao. Wait lang, guys, ha.
07:40.0
Kunin ko yung para makita nyo talagang
07:59.6
Para maniwala kayo sa akin.
08:01.9
Sabi ko, baka ang problema
08:03.2
sa, ano ko, sa mga earphones ko,
08:05.6
ayun, na nagdagdat ko yung scotch tape.
08:07.6
Kung maalala nyo yung first year natin
08:09.1
nagvlogging, nakikita nyo, ito yung
08:11.2
scotch tape na nakikita nyo, diba?
08:13.7
Yung mga, naalala nyo yung mga
08:15.5
first year natin magvlog lang, oh, yung
08:17.2
panaw na elections. Parating nakaganyan
08:19.3
ako, diba? Tapos nakikita nyo yung mga
08:20.9
nakaskatch tape, scotch tape.
08:22.2
Tapos, lukot-lukot
08:24.5
na ganyan, oh, yan. Ito,
08:26.2
nandyan pa rin. So, dinagdagan ko pa ng
08:30.6
tsaka isa pa dito. So, kitang-kita
08:32.6
talaga yung pagka-ilokano
08:34.4
natin. Toto Bigay,
08:36.6
never give up, alright?
08:38.1
Never give up. So, natest ko naman.
08:41.9
Nag-test ako. So, baka,
08:44.0
sabi ko, baka dahil luma na itong phone na isang
08:46.2
ginagamit natin, baka yun yung dahilan. Kaya,
08:48.8
actually, nag-research ako, baka
08:50.9
kasi naiinis ako sa
08:52.1
iPhone, halos walang improvement, eh.
08:55.1
Diba? Kasi, syempre,
08:56.3
natitry ko yung iPhone, every other generation
08:58.5
or so, walang improvement. So, siguro, iti-check ko
09:00.3
ngayon yung Samsung na lang.
09:02.0
O, yung mga iba dyan, may Samsung dyan,
09:04.2
anong suggestion nyo na, ano, kahit
09:06.5
yung mga last year or something like that
09:08.5
na parang hindi mahal.
09:11.5
Baka mas magandang
09:12.2
Samsung, kasi ang habol din natin,
09:14.3
guys, yung selfie camera.
09:18.7
baka yun na lang kunin ko.
09:19.8
Kasi yung iPhone, halos walang improvement.
09:22.1
Yung iPhone 14, 15,
09:23.7
halos walang change. 13, 14,
09:26.0
konting improvement. Yung 12,
09:27.9
parang mas maganda pa sa 13.
09:29.6
S23, o yun, siguro.
09:31.6
Huwag yung latest, S24 ba yun? Masyadong mahal.
09:36.0
mag-suggest na lang kayo, kasi iniisip ko,
09:38.0
mas maganda talaga na, ano, eh,
09:39.3
Samsung na lang kung magsi-selfie videos
09:41.7
tayo. Kasi, alam, nakikita nyo naman, luma talaga
09:43.4
itong isang phone ko.
09:45.3
So, it's not worth to buy iPhone.
09:47.8
Namamahalan ako for what you're getting out of it.
09:49.9
For ease na lang. So, siguro, Samsung na lang.
09:52.1
Okay. Kung may suggestions lang kayo.
09:54.3
Thank you, by the way, guys, yung mga nag-suggestion
09:56.0
dun sa professional camera.
09:58.1
So, salamat naman. Nakagamit tayo
10:00.1
ng professional camera. But, yun nga,
10:02.0
problema naman sa professional camera, hindi ko magamit yan
10:03.9
sa Facebook platform. So, kailangan natin
10:05.8
ng phone. Ang suggestion ko, siguro, Samsung
10:08.7
Honor, yung China.
10:11.8
Problema ko kasi sa China, guys.
10:13.7
Alam nyo naman yung nature of work
10:17.7
So, actually, meron ako isang
10:18.9
phone na mati, no? Kaso,
10:20.8
may TikTok na dun.
10:22.1
No offense sa TikTok. Pero,
10:24.2
dahil nandun na yung TikTok, hindi ko na malagay
10:26.0
yung mga ibang Facebook or apps ko.
10:27.9
So, ang tawag dyan, guys,
10:31.8
Digital hygiene. So, kung may
10:33.7
nalagay na akong medyo dodgy na,
10:35.9
hindi ko na siya magamit dun sa mga
10:38.5
platforms or communications na
10:41.9
ginagamit natin. Kasi, guys,
10:46.0
accounts tong mga to. So, hindi ito
10:47.8
biro. So, yun ang problema ko. Kaya, yung
10:49.9
lumang ginagamit kong backup. Kaya,
10:52.1
so, yun ang dahilan. Kasi, na-test ko talaga
10:53.9
ito, guys. Promise. Nilagay ko pa ng
10:55.7
scotch tape na isa pa dito.
10:57.6
Isa dito, isa dito. Dapat gumagana,
11:00.2
eh. So, baka yung phone talaga yung problema.
11:03.8
thank you sa suggestion niya. Siguro,
11:07.3
magandang Honor. Mas maganda pa
11:09.9
sa Samsung. Kaso, yun nga, China, eh.
11:12.5
No offense. Pero, for
11:13.8
security reasons, medyo
11:15.3
malabo. Maganda siya
11:17.8
for video and all. Pero, kasi, kailangan ko for
11:19.6
Facebook and all. Anyway,
11:22.1
iPhone 15 mag-iPhone. Meron na tayo. Ayoko
11:23.9
ng iPhone na mahal masyado. Tapos,
11:26.0
hindi naman ganun kaganda yung camera.
11:28.5
Okay. Thanks, guys.
11:30.0
Again, sa suggestions niya. Maganda
11:31.9
rin yung suggestion niyo, guys, dun sa professional
11:33.7
camera and all. So, thank you so much. May mga na video
11:35.8
din ako. Marami akong... So, kailangan
11:38.0
ko upuan yan. Yung mga videos na nakuha natin
11:40.0
sa Tokyo, videos na nakuha natin sa
11:41.7
Washington, D.C. at God willing, dun sa mga susunod
11:43.8
natin visit. So, I'm just gathering things to
11:45.8
put them together. Alright?
11:48.0
But, from my understanding,
11:50.1
mas magandang Samsung sa iPhone.
11:52.1
Especially sa selfie.
11:54.6
Mas magandang Chinese sa lahat. Kaso,
11:56.3
yun nga. Hindi ko malagay yung mga...
11:58.8
Alam nyo na. Okay.
12:00.3
Alam nyo na yung mga limitations natin, mga kameta.
12:02.8
Kaya, pag may TikTok
12:04.2
or something, burner phone na kagad yan.
12:07.9
Sorry na. Sorry na ano tayo. I'm just
12:09.9
trying to apologize, guys, dun sa
12:12.1
bad audio kapon. Kasi,
12:14.2
nakita ko marami nag-comment ng bad audio,
12:16.2
bad audio. So, na-hurt ako
12:18.2
kasi pinag-irapan natin
12:20.5
yun. Kahit sobrang jet lag ako yun,
12:22.1
all. Go pa rin ako dun sa discussion namin.
12:24.3
Almost 3 hours, di ba? 9pm
12:26.2
until 11.30 ang discussion namin.
12:28.3
So, napaisip ako.
12:30.1
Ano pong problema? Baka itong mga
12:31.8
earphones ko? So, baka it's the phone.
12:34.8
So, let's see. Let's look at the options.
12:38.8
Yun na lang gift ko sa sarili ko.
12:40.6
Hindi, masyado mahal. Maganap na lang tayo
12:42.1
nang baka may second hand, no?
12:46.0
Let's get back to discussion, guys.
12:48.2
I hope you accept my sincere
12:50.2
apologies dun sa bad audio.
12:52.1
And all of that. Anyways, the good news naman is
12:54.0
yung finalized na clear version po.
12:57.0
Although, hindi yung
13:01.7
na na-upload na natin sa YouTube.
13:04.2
So, two of them are already there on YouTube,
13:05.9
mga kameta. Of course, yung discussion natin
13:08.0
sa whether this is the worst Senate
13:11.9
At, of course, ang sagot is no in a sense
13:14.1
that things can get worse.
13:16.2
And then, yung pangalawa is
13:20.0
Mahaba kong usapan niya. Almost one hour kami
13:22.0
nag-usap yan because we talked about Brazil, etc.
13:24.4
Now, let's go back to the
13:26.1
Philippines. But before I go...
13:29.2
Guys, before tayo
13:31.8
diskusyon ng Chacha and all,
13:36.5
can someone just explain
13:38.9
ano ba ang nangyayari dito?
13:43.8
So, eto guys. Remember, nag-discuss
13:46.0
kami ng episode ni
13:49.2
Ronald Llamas na nandun na sa
13:52.0
kabilang channel ngayon.
13:53.8
Hindi eto guys, diba? Din-discuss natin itong
13:58.5
Spirit of ETSA. And itong
13:59.9
problema kung saan, sa ating
14:03.2
ang mga Duterte po, ay ina-appropriate
14:08.4
po nila yung ETSA for their own
14:12.2
So, nakita natin na si Digong
14:14.2
openly discussed the possibility of
14:16.0
people power against Marcos.
14:17.6
Dun sa isa sa mga threats niya
14:19.7
nun nag-speech sila sa Davao.
14:22.0
January. And then
14:23.9
more recently, nakikita natin na pumaposition
14:25.9
ng mga Dutertes, including the current vice president
14:27.8
dito sa issue ng ETSA. So, there was an initial
14:29.9
statement that came out kung saan
14:32.3
sinabi ni Sarah Duterte na
14:33.9
something like, you know,
14:35.6
ETSA is about the usual
14:38.0
stuff, diba? It's about people power,
14:40.0
people fighting for their rights, gina. And then
14:41.8
biglang nadelete yan. So,
14:45.8
Ito yung nakikita ko. So, ETSA
14:47.6
anniversary message. Ito nakita kong
14:50.0
version. On this day, we commemorate the
14:51.9
brave souls who stood united on the streets
14:53.8
of ETSA, fighting for democracy and freedom.
14:56.5
Their courage and determination paved
14:57.9
the way for a better Philippines and their sacrifices
15:00.1
and will never be forgotten.
15:01.8
And we celebrate this momentous occasion. Let us
15:03.7
remember the lesson of ETSA, the power
15:05.9
of unity, the strength of
15:07.9
the Philippine spirit. Okay.
15:09.9
But ito yung importante. And the importance of
15:11.8
standing up for what is right.
15:14.6
So, let us continue to build a
15:15.9
nation where justice, peace, and prosperity, blah, blah, blah,
15:18.1
blah, blah, blah. So, I think that
15:19.8
was the part na ano eh.
15:21.9
Na medyo tricky. And the
15:23.9
importance of standing up for what is right.
15:25.9
So, may pagka-challenging
15:30.2
And the next thing you know,
15:31.8
natanggal itong mensahe na ito.
15:33.6
Basis ang mga reports na nakita natin.
15:35.6
So, nag-release ng
15:36.6
clarificatory statement
15:39.9
itong bisipresidente natin
15:41.8
or opisina niya. So,
15:43.8
basahin niya yan. Kasi,
15:45.6
to be honest, parang
15:51.9
I don't know how to say it. Parang
15:53.7
this is anything but
15:55.6
clarificatory. Diba?
15:57.7
Yun ang inaisip ko eh.
16:03.9
So, ito yung sinabi niya.
16:05.3
What I said in 2017.
16:07.8
Parang ang tagal na yan. What I said
16:09.5
in 2017 regarding the February 25th
16:11.7
at sa university has
16:13.7
never changed. My position
16:15.7
remains the same. So, kailangan ba natin i-Google?
16:18.2
Or kailangan pa tayo pumunta sa
16:19.8
ano? Sa, um, ngayon naman,
16:21.6
bad yung audio naman sa YouTube.
16:25.2
Test ka na natin ito.
16:27.8
Nasasabot tayo talaga. Yata tayo.
16:31.9
Okay naman yung response ng iba dito.
16:37.5
Itong sketch tape.
16:39.6
Itong sketch tape na ito.
16:41.6
Ito, I did not, ito.
16:43.5
So, ang weird. Mag-release ka ng
16:45.3
statement. Tapos parang essentially sinasabi mo, refer to
16:47.3
my 2017 statement. Parang
16:49.3
i-Google pa namin yan.
16:51.6
Ano to? Parang academic references.
16:53.6
I-footnote mo pa yan. I did not
16:55.6
intend to issue a statement this year.
16:57.7
Saan yun? Napilitan ka?
16:59.3
As I did not the previous year.
17:05.7
ayan pumangit daw.
17:08.8
Nag-trabaw. Okay na yan.
17:12.8
I removed the ETSA
17:13.8
anniversary post from my social media
17:16.7
page. I hope this will put the
17:18.6
matter to rest. Ang labo,
17:20.8
diba? Yung parang,
17:21.6
parang sinabi niya,
17:23.0
paalam nalang kayo dyan. Hanapin nyo lang
17:24.6
yung sinabi ko noong 2017.
17:27.3
Alright? Hanapin.
17:29.2
Nagugulo ka kasi, Noymi eh.
17:30.9
Okay naman yung audio eh. Ikaw lang
17:32.7
nagreklamo. Ayan, natuloy.
17:34.8
Alam mo, minsan bago kayo magreklamo si Karadino,
17:36.7
hindi sa inyo yung problema. Okay?
17:38.8
Huwag nyo ako i-gaslight. Okay naman daw
17:40.8
yung pumangit. Lalo daw yung
17:42.5
ginamit ko itong sketch tape na earphones.
17:44.7
Anyways, guys. Ito, I did not intend to issue
17:48.2
I did not intend to issue a statement. So, bakit ka ba
17:50.6
nag-issue ng statement ngayon? Tapos,
17:52.6
in-emphasize pa rin na hindi rin siya nag-issue
17:55.0
ng statement last year. I mean,
17:56.6
what's going on here? Because of
17:58.8
this, I removed the ETSA anniversary pros
18:01.6
I don't know, guys. Something's going on.
18:05.5
communications ngayon, no?
18:08.8
I don't know. I cannot even call this
18:10.6
passive-aggressive.
18:13.0
Definitely, it's not clarificatory
18:14.9
statement dahil ang labo.
18:17.3
Parang mas malabo pa ito.
18:20.6
let me be absolutely clear. I appreciate
18:24.2
Vice President is
18:26.4
constantly tries to
18:28.4
pay due respect dun sa ating
18:30.8
mga moral brothers and
18:36.4
greetings and all of that.
18:38.8
I think that's a very good thing. I always appreciate
18:40.7
them with them. At the same time,
18:42.7
I hope this is not a way to kind of
18:44.7
say na, you know,
18:46.9
like, to go the regional
18:50.6
after all, she's the Vice President of
18:52.5
all Filipinos. Diba?
18:55.5
at the very least also, we
18:58.3
want a certain degree of
19:00.6
clarity of purpose.
19:03.0
Masyadong malabo ito eh. Parang
19:04.4
all over the place ito eh. Parang
19:06.4
what I said in 2017,
19:08.7
like, as if pinafollow natin every
19:10.5
statement na sinasabing nyo since ever. Like,
19:18.5
I know. I just...
19:20.6
I just don't want to be nice.
19:22.3
Tapos, sasabing, I did not intend to issue a statement
19:24.3
this year. So, ano yun, napilitan ka.
19:26.7
And then, I did not last year.
19:29.1
So, niremove ko yung this year.
19:30.6
Tapos, anyway, um,
19:34.5
na lang sa atin, honestly.
19:36.9
Good luck talaga sa atin. Good luck
19:38.4
talaga sa atin. Kasi,
19:42.4
nanood na lang ako ng vlogs ni Madam, eh.
19:44.6
Yung mga vlogs niya sa kitchen daw,
19:46.3
yung mga ganun. Ito, guys, oh.
19:49.0
May nag-send sa atin.
19:50.6
Eh, mahal na mahal ko kayo, eh.
19:52.4
Yung mga makulit din kayo, mag-send kayo
19:54.2
ng mga... Oh, yung mga
19:56.3
mag-send na, ano, ah, yung mga
19:57.6
interesting stuff. Ito, guys, ah.
20:04.1
Hindi ko nalang sabi yung sino nag-send.
20:05.6
Hi! Gusto ko lang i-share sa inyong
20:08.2
aming kusina. Ayan.
20:13.3
I love you, Amontra Puday!
20:15.1
I love you, Amontra Puday!
20:15.2
I love you, Amontra Puday!
20:19.2
I love you, Amontra Puday!
20:19.2
I love you, Amontra Puday!
20:19.2
Ayan nalang mga pinapanood ko ngayon
20:23.0
kay madam, mga ganyan nalang, kasi
20:24.9
hindi ko mag-gets yung mga
20:29.4
Tulungan mo ang LV na
20:30.9
Trapudzay! Ayan, yung mga
20:32.9
ganyan nalang. Hi! Gusto ko lang
20:34.9
i-share sa inyong aming kusina.
20:39.0
Hi! Ayan, ganyan nalang
20:41.0
mga guys. Next time. Hindi na tayo. Ayan na, ayan na.
20:49.2
Hindi lang ito, Jai.
20:51.9
So, wala. Mga ganyan nalang
20:53.6
pinapanood ko ngayon kay madam.
20:55.6
Baka may mas clarity pa dyan.
20:58.0
Okay. Okay, okay, okay.
21:00.3
Na, ito, guys, ah. Of course,
21:01.8
I know, objectively, bentang-benta ito
21:03.4
sa marami sa ating mga
21:05.1
kababayan, but obviously, as you know,
21:07.4
we don't do analysis based on popularity.
21:09.9
Diba? Kasi kung gano'n
21:11.3
ang base yan, edi pag-usapan na lang natin
21:13.1
si, ano na lang, Willie Reveillame na lang.
21:15.3
Everyday na lang, mag-Willie na lang tayo.
21:17.2
I don't know. O, mag-Robbie,
21:19.2
nude na lang tayo. Diba?
21:21.0
But, ah, yun nga.
21:22.9
At least, may more, ano, may details
21:24.9
and clarity yung mga ganyan vlogs ni madam
21:28.5
supposedly clarificatory statement.
21:33.5
balikan natin yung original,
21:36.8
which is yung, ah,
21:39.2
which is yung, ano,
21:41.1
which is yung tatay.
21:43.0
Literally, yung tatay.
21:44.6
Balikan natin ito si tatay. Si tatay,
21:46.7
as usual, may change of heart na naman,
21:50.6
Or, I don't know, change of
21:52.1
change of tone, ano,
21:54.9
nag-change tone na naman siya. So, eto,
21:56.8
biglang, si tatay Digong,
21:59.2
hindi lang, hindi against
22:03.1
hindi lang, hindi against
22:07.4
Par sa kanya ngayon, bigla,
22:09.2
Chacha is a breath
22:10.9
of fresh air. Ayan, talaga
22:12.9
si tatay Digong. And then, nung tinanong pa siya
22:15.0
ukol kay Kiboloy,
22:17.0
ito pa, interesting, ha? Tinanong pa siya ukol sa
22:18.9
Kiboloy, you would have expected
22:21.0
him to stand by his good friend
22:27.5
wala, parang deflection
22:29.5
lang ginawa niya dito, eh.
22:30.7
Tingnan nyo, guys. O, tingnan natin itong
22:32.7
Again, of course, you know
22:34.8
why I'm doing this, because all of these things are connected.
22:37.4
When a politician
22:38.9
of Duterte's stature, with quite some
22:40.7
influence, when he makes statements,
22:42.8
you have to understand those statements within a particular
22:44.7
context, diba? At, of course,
22:46.9
you wonder, anong stance ni Digong
22:58.5
Sa kanyang kaibigan, diba?
23:01.3
Kasi parang nagsichange tone
23:02.8
na talaga si tatay ngayon ulit, eh. Pero,
23:04.7
I won't be, I won't be, ito, ha?
23:09.2
Ito, ito, tinanong siya dito.
23:15.0
Nung tinanong siya dun sa issue ni Kiboloy
23:17.1
na binigay siya ng bags of
23:18.8
guns daw. Ito yung siyami niya.
23:20.2
Ako pa ba ang mabilaybir sa kanyan?
23:23.5
Ako pa daw mag-deliver
23:24.9
sa kanyan ng kanyan.
23:26.1
Ako pa ba ang mabilaybir sa kanyan?
23:29.2
Ah, ba't mainang internet
23:30.7
yung bukas? O masinggan?
23:33.3
Bakit ba si Pastor mabigay
23:34.8
ng baril sa akin? Saan ba siya magkuka?
23:39.8
Kung magsabi siya wala isang baril,
23:42.2
ako pa ba ang mabilaybir sa kanyan?
23:47.7
Ako pa daw mag-deliver sa kanyan?
23:48.8
Sa kanyan ang masinggan.
23:50.1
But you see, that's what Duterte does.
23:51.6
Whenever you put him under a serious question
23:53.9
na potentially incriminating,
23:56.0
ang ginagawa lang niya,
23:57.6
papalitan lang niya yung topic
23:58.8
tapos magpapatawa lang siya.
24:02.9
one of the communication strengths
24:04.5
hindi ko nga napansin ko.
24:06.3
Yung tactical and strategic usage
24:08.8
of humor. Tactical,
24:10.7
in the sense na minsan, yun yung pang-deflect niya.
24:12.6
Kunyari, very contentious yung issue
24:14.6
or medyo alanganin siya.
24:16.5
Magpapatawa lang siya. Wala na, tapos na usapan.
24:19.9
People will just remember the jokes and all.
24:21.7
And sometimes very inappropriate jokes, unfortunately.
24:23.9
Sometimes jokes that are not even jokes.
24:25.4
They're more like incendiary, offensive things.
24:28.9
And then there are times na strategic talaga siya.
24:30.9
Hindi lang siyang tactical.
24:33.2
he's just using humor in general
24:36.2
to reinforce yung kanyang populist appeal.
24:39.4
Ang dami na, ang dami ko na-meet ng tao na
24:41.6
eh yung si Tatay, di kong nakakarelate yun
24:44.2
kasi nakakatawa siya.
24:45.5
Parang, alam mo yun guys, yung parang mga ginagawa natin
24:48.6
So, I understand why siguro the vice president
24:52.8
is trying to just do yung mga videos na gano'n.
24:54.9
Kasi siguro napansin niya, it's easier to get
24:57.0
to get closer to the heart of people
25:03.5
pag gumagamit ka ng mga ganyang humor.
25:05.5
Kaysa yung, you know, you get very serious and all
25:08.2
and then you make faux pas,
25:09.5
you make a mistake here,
25:12.1
tapos ikaw pa yung education secretary.
25:14.1
So, I see what's going on.
25:15.5
I think the advice is, ayun, magpatawa na lang tayo.
25:18.6
Liar or something like that.
25:19.6
Kasi kitang-kita natin eh, gumagana talaga sa Tatay niya eh.
25:22.3
In fact, kanina, I was going through videos.
25:25.9
May nakita na tayong videos sa TikTok, for instance.
25:29.5
And I think that's very important.
25:31.1
Balikan natin yan.
25:31.9
I'll post it separately.
25:33.6
Ito yung video ni Digong nung debate nila sa TV5.
25:37.5
Diba, I think dun talaga Digong was able to be the breakout star.
25:41.8
I think that debate, he did horribly in terms of substance,
25:44.2
but in terms of audience, yung pakanggaling niya yung...
25:47.0
Ito yung debate na pinagtatawan,
25:48.6
ganun niya si Maroas,
25:49.7
uy, kanina ka pa nagsiyar, pangatlong beses mo na yan.
25:52.0
Yung mga gano'n, yung mga banter niya,
25:53.8
tapos yung, diba, sila Grace po,
25:56.6
napaka-respectful, stateswoman-like,
25:58.5
nag-greet si Lord Devere, ganyan-ganyan.
26:00.6
Tapos si Digong, sorry, wala akong kilala sa inyo eh.
26:03.1
Hayin na lang ako dun sa mga indiminensyo.
26:04.9
Yung mga gano'n siya.
26:05.7
So, meron siyang strategic deployment of humor talaga
26:09.6
to make a strong populist appeal.
26:12.4
So, humor, dark humor,
26:14.5
and sometimes very, you know, offensive,
26:18.6
humor is what he uses in order to reinforce
26:21.2
yung kanyang emotional, affective connection sa tao.
26:23.4
So, kitang-kita natin kay Digong yan,
26:25.4
yung ganyan sa...
26:26.1
Or tactically uses it for deflecting,
26:29.2
for deflecting criticism,
26:30.6
or if there's a question.
26:31.6
So, dito, tinanong siya about kibolo and guns,
26:33.9
nagpatawa na lang siya,
26:34.8
ay, hindi, but, but, yung pare pong magbigay sa'yo,
26:36.7
ako pong magbigay yung ganyan-ganyan,
26:37.9
machine gun, ganyan-ganyan,
26:39.8
So, you see that,
26:40.7
he really, there's something going on there.
26:43.7
Now, my sense is,
26:44.5
Sarah is trying to replicate that.
26:46.1
I just, I just don't know how successful it is.
26:50.1
Because I just don't think it's at the same level as Digong.
26:53.6
I think Digong still does it very, very differently.
26:56.5
Kaya hindi ako nagtataka,
26:57.5
yung kaibigan natin na si Lele Claudio,
27:00.3
Professor Claudio,
27:01.5
for him, Digong is the master rhetorician.
27:06.2
Rhetorician, not speaker,
27:07.8
in the sense that he's not a very good speaker,
27:09.4
like, ang sabog yung,
27:10.8
hindi mo alam kung saan papunta yung discussion,
27:12.7
but the impact is very strong.
27:15.1
The impact is very strong.
27:17.1
especially when he speaks in his own,
27:20.0
by the way, Visaya is a language,
27:21.6
it's not a dialect,
27:22.9
in the same way that,
27:24.1
Ilocano is a language,
27:26.7
it's not a dialect,
27:27.5
it's not a variation of Tagalog.
27:30.2
You can say there's a Batangueño version of Tagalog,
27:33.5
it could be a dialect,
27:34.5
but when it comes to Visaya,
27:36.0
it's a completely different language,
27:37.4
from Tagalog or Filipino.
27:39.6
I think when Digong is speaking in Visaya,
27:42.1
even if I don't understand it really,
27:44.5
eh, konti lang yan there,
27:46.4
I could see yung,
27:48.6
yung audience impact niya.
27:51.6
yung mga ganang-ganang siya,
27:53.6
yung parang ginigigil-gigil niya,
27:55.4
yung sasabihin niya.
27:56.8
even a sound that doesn't speak Visaya,
27:58.4
I could see the strength of that strategy.
28:01.1
So, hindi ako nagtataka na minsan,
28:02.4
siguro si Sarah is trying to pull off something similar,
28:05.1
but it's not at the same level.
28:06.4
Kaya nga sabi ko,
28:07.6
one thing interesting to watch here is Bastet.
28:10.2
Because I think Bastet has a better grasp,
28:12.8
or better ability to replicate yung father niya.
28:15.6
Except, of course,
28:17.0
at least one thing,
28:18.6
that Sarah and her father have in common
28:20.2
is that both of them have legal training.
28:22.5
So, that gives them a certain kind of
28:25.1
pizzazz or some sort of authority
28:28.1
na I think gives them some sort of cover also
28:32.4
for things that they do.
28:34.8
I mean, they can always say,
28:36.0
bakit ako abogado?
28:37.4
Paano mo sabihin ng ganyan-ganyan?
28:38.9
So, I'm just telling you,
28:40.2
all of these things are related.
28:41.7
Na pinag-iisipan lahat yan.
28:43.6
Even yung mga malabong clarificatory statement.
28:46.2
And then magpapatawa ka na lang on the sides.
28:48.6
You're playing to different audiences.
28:50.6
And you're using different cadence.
28:52.7
Using different communication strategies
28:54.9
to reach out to different audience
28:56.5
and have an overall impact.
28:59.3
I was also looking at how Digon will say something about Kiboloy.
29:02.2
Because as far as BBM is concerned,
29:04.3
at least si BBM may statement siya kay Kiboloy.
29:08.0
ang statement ni BBM kay Kiboloy is
29:10.6
huwag kang matakot.
29:11.6
There's nothing to fear.
29:14.1
And then nung tinanong siya about the assassination plot,
29:17.2
Napatawa na lang siya.
29:31.4
Bati si BBM napatawa na lang siya
29:33.5
nung tinanong siya about the assassination.
29:34.6
Sino naman mag-a-assassinate sa kanya?
29:36.9
Magpakita ka na lang para walang ano.
29:39.9
essentially you have
29:40.9
essentially you have both BBM and Digon
29:44.2
trying to just downplay the drama and all of that.
29:48.8
ano yung sinisabi ng ibang tao.
29:50.6
And this is where you see Digon
29:51.9
is such a consummate politician.
29:56.4
he's a total politician.
29:59.3
this is not about ideology.
30:01.6
Hindi ito sa consistencies ng sinisabi niya.
30:03.8
It's not even about the substance of his argument.
30:06.1
Ang style ni Digon lang is
30:09.6
What worked in January
30:10.9
may not work in February.
30:12.3
So, iba yung ko yung sasabihin ko.
30:17.2
Eh di magpatawa ako.
30:18.6
Kung masyada naman ako magpatawa.
30:20.0
Baka makalimutan niya ng presidente ako
30:22.5
Eh di remind natin ng tao
30:23.7
na medyo matalinyo din tayo.
30:25.1
Medyo abogado din tayo.
30:26.9
You see what I'm saying?
30:28.1
So, he's a consummate politician.
30:30.4
Very, very politician.
30:31.7
Now, he's a different kind of politician from BBM
30:33.8
because the BBM politician is a kind of
30:35.6
kunyari above the phrase style of politician.
30:38.6
But kay Digon is a consummate populist kind of politician.
30:41.7
So, parating tinitingnan ko
30:43.0
what is Sara trying to do
30:44.4
in terms of replicating
30:47.6
Again, none of this is an endorsement
30:50.0
of the approach of Digon to politics.
30:53.7
As you know, I'm very, very critical
30:56.1
Kasi para sa akin,
30:57.4
misa pang barangay level lang.
30:58.9
Although, no offense sa mga barangay chairman.
31:00.6
Maraming tayong kilala ng mga barangay chairman
31:02.4
na mas mati ng mag-isip
31:04.2
at mas magaling magsalita.
31:09.7
and I cannot deny
31:12.7
it does have a very strong appeal.
31:14.9
And I don't think it helps people
31:16.4
in the opposition.
31:17.0
The pink movement.
31:19.3
Even yung mga loyalists
31:20.5
na to just dismiss lang Digon.
31:22.7
Or just make fun of Digon and all.
31:24.5
I mean, he's funny.
31:25.5
You can laugh at him.
31:26.4
You can laugh with him.
31:27.7
But at the end of the day,
31:29.1
ang lakas nung ano eh.
31:30.1
Ang lakas pa rin nung hatak nila eh.
31:31.9
Yun yung sinasabi ko parati.
31:33.5
Kaya I'm not surprised
31:34.6
na BBM will try to keep things on an even keel.
31:37.7
Having said that,
31:39.6
so while I disagree with si Ronaldo
31:41.8
na the Bardagulan will come to a
31:46.0
I'm not surprised that the Bardagulan will come to a denouement.
31:47.0
Meaning some sort of culmination
31:48.9
in the short term.
31:50.9
So far, I've been proven right.
31:52.6
Culmination did not happen.
31:53.9
Even if yung minuramuran ni Tatay
31:59.5
Ayaw pa rin ng D-Day yung isa.
32:02.0
So now, Digon also sensing
32:04.1
na yung kapila is not so easy to trigger.
32:06.7
He's also changing tone.
32:07.7
So this is actually a fight of two types of
32:09.9
traditional politicians.
32:11.9
Both very consummate politicians.
32:13.7
Consummate politicians si BBM.
32:15.3
Consummate politicians si Duterte.
32:17.0
And I think Duterte is smart enough to realize
32:20.2
na pagdating dito sa issue ng Chacha,
32:23.7
gravity is favoring the administration side.
32:27.5
There's just too many people
32:30.1
doon sa ruling establishment,
32:32.5
sa Kongreso, among others,
32:34.6
who are invested na dito sa Chacha.
32:36.8
And you could see, despite all the drama of
32:42.1
all those statements na nirelease,
32:43.9
unanimous statement by the Senate
32:47.0
about people's initiative,
32:48.8
despite all of the backlash against
32:53.0
and all of the shenanigans,
32:54.9
by some of the congressmen out there,
32:57.5
tuloy pa rin ang usapan.
33:00.7
and I think we partially discussed this
33:02.6
with si Ronald kaapon,
33:04.4
and I think you also listened to this discussion
33:06.4
siguro kanina with Christian Esquera,
33:07.9
or ongoing pa rin ba?
33:12.3
mukhang there is a kind of a
33:15.3
or some sort of a,
33:17.0
least common denominator,
33:19.8
or a working consensus na
33:21.4
between Senate and Kongreso,
33:23.5
hindi gagamitin ng Kongreso
33:26.0
yung kanilang numerical superiority
33:27.8
to essentially marginalize the entire Senate.
33:31.7
But it looks like,
33:33.2
there may be enough numbers
33:34.6
to push for some sort of charter change.
33:38.5
Or, at the very least,
33:40.7
and dito mahalaga yung sinasabi ni BBM
33:42.4
na-discuss natin shortly,
33:43.4
there will be a push for a plebiscite,
33:45.7
whereby essentially ma-formalize
33:48.8
and potentially ma-institutionalize
33:51.2
etong constitutional change.
33:52.9
So first, let's quickly talk about
33:59.0
etong mga monologue style,
34:02.5
there are a bunch of people there
34:05.0
who make comments about,
34:06.0
Richard, bakit ka,
34:07.2
you know, why do you go around,
34:08.5
you know, beat around the bush?
34:09.7
Why don't you go straight to your discussion?
34:12.0
alright, if you're in my classroom,
34:13.6
if you have seen me in think tanks,
34:15.7
if you have seen me in,
34:17.1
you know, if you have followed my stuff,
34:18.6
you know, in media,
34:20.3
I go straight to the point.
34:21.9
But if there's one thing I realize
34:23.4
from the populist and all,
34:25.3
and mga buljak style,
34:26.4
mga bloggers and all is that,
34:28.1
people also appreciate
34:29.2
the kind of a monologue style
34:30.5
whereby you're, you know,
34:31.3
you're playing all these games
34:33.3
and all, actually not games,
34:34.6
you know, you're taking people
34:36.3
on a journey of a conversation.
34:37.8
You're thinking things out loud
34:39.1
and you essentially are allowing people
34:41.0
to think along with you
34:42.3
while you go to the meat of the discussion.
34:48.5
I would say it's an Aristotelian approach, right?
34:51.2
Mahabang usapan yan.
34:52.4
The Socratic-Platonic approach is
34:55.0
you start with some great idea
34:56.4
and then immediately you break it down, diba?
34:58.5
The Aristotelian approach is
34:59.6
you build from ground
35:00.8
and then you move above, diba?
35:02.4
Kaya yung monologue style and all,
35:04.3
that's the approach, alright?
35:05.4
So everything I do, guys, here,
35:06.7
it's not just like that.
35:08.3
Pinag-isipan natin yan, right?
35:09.7
And it's also based on
35:11.3
thousands of vlogs we have done, right?
35:14.3
If you go to my YouTube,
35:15.4
I think we have already uploaded
35:16.6
1,500 vlogs already, right?
35:19.3
So everything we do there is based on
35:21.2
experience, based on interaction.
35:23.5
And I'll be very honest, guys.
35:24.8
Yeah, yung inductive, deductive, all of that.
35:26.6
But it's just not inductive, deductive.
35:28.3
There's also kind of a rhetorical build-up style.
35:31.3
mahabang usapan yan.
35:32.9
But what I'm telling you guys is,
35:36.5
this is a conversation we're having.
35:38.6
Because as much as I'm,
35:40.5
you know, I'm discussing this issue,
35:41.7
tinitingnan ko yung comments nyo,
35:42.9
iniisip ko rin yung mga
35:44.8
dinidiscuss natin.
35:46.1
So actually, we're learning together.
35:47.5
So I hope you guys appreciate
35:48.4
what we're doing here, okay?
35:50.3
In fairness naman,
35:51.4
in fairness naman,
35:52.2
it looks like, you know,
35:53.1
marami tayong mga
35:53.9
supporters all around the world.
35:56.2
thank you so much dun sa mga
35:57.3
kameta natin from
35:58.3
United Arab Emirates and Italy.
36:00.6
So hindi lang tayo nag-number one dito
36:03.5
consistently among the top podcast tayo dito.
36:06.0
Hindi lang dito sa Pilipinas,
36:08.8
Salamat din sa mga kababayan natin
36:10.6
in other countries around the world.
36:12.2
Especially United Arab Emirates,
36:14.3
Italy, et cetera.
36:15.5
Even sa Australia, Singapore.
36:16.9
hindi lang tayo nag-top 100, top 50.
36:19.3
Misan, top 20 pa tayo
36:20.8
or top 10 pa tayo
36:21.7
sa mga political podcast nila.
36:23.0
So I really appreciate that.
36:24.9
marami sa ating mga kababayan
36:26.4
na-appreciate nila yung
36:27.2
how we're approaching these things.
36:29.0
going back to this,
36:32.4
what we're trying to do here is,
36:34.3
gusto ko makita nyo na,
36:36.6
when we discuss an issue,
36:37.9
we're not just discussing the issue
36:39.4
based on what's there in the news.
36:41.6
We're not just discussing
36:42.5
an issue of cha-cha
36:44.3
you have to understand
36:44.9
the psychological games here.
36:47.2
You have to understand
36:48.1
the biography of people
36:49.3
we're talking about.
36:49.9
You have to understand
36:51.8
what I'm doing is,
36:52.4
I'm giving you a sense of
36:54.9
of Tigong's algorithm.
36:56.8
Because pinag-aralan ko na mabuti
36:58.7
for more than 6-7 years.
37:00.2
first year pa lang niya.
37:01.1
Nakasulat na tayo
37:02.3
But I never pretended
37:03.9
to fully understand
37:04.8
what was going on.
37:07.1
when I pay attention to something,
37:08.4
I obsessively pay attention to it.
37:14.1
I had more interesting people
37:16.3
But it is what it is.
37:18.4
This is about our country.
37:19.7
We have to understand
37:20.9
with our leaders,
37:21.6
with the people out there,
37:22.5
whether you like them or not.
37:24.3
And also with BBM.
37:26.1
As you can see, guys,
37:27.9
I discussed BBMs.
37:30.6
many things that we predicted
37:36.2
Including my articles
37:37.2
in the first days
37:40.4
But at the same time,
37:41.3
I'm never complacent
37:43.0
in the sense that
37:44.5
yung gagawin nila.
37:45.1
No, I'm constantly
37:51.8
Ayun na naman tayo.
37:54.5
Okay, let's go back to this.
37:55.5
So, speaking of Digong,
37:56.8
being a conscient politician,
37:58.0
so, biglang may konting
38:00.9
nag-switch gear siya.
38:03.3
this switch gear thing
38:04.1
is something you guys
38:04.7
have to get used to.
38:06.1
This is what politicians do.
38:08.4
Because they have no ideology.
38:10.0
They have no coherent vision.
38:12.9
They're just tactical.
38:15.1
That's a term that you guys
38:16.1
have to keep in mind.
38:19.3
In fact, I got the term
38:20.2
from the very good historian
38:23.9
who tried to understand
38:25.2
how, for instance,
38:26.0
regulators in the United States
38:27.6
responded to financial crisis.
38:29.9
The term tactical situational
38:31.3
means you're driven
38:34.2
You're driven by,
38:41.3
kind of calculus.
38:42.6
It's about survival.
38:43.4
It's about going from
38:45.2
one crisis to the other
38:46.7
and going from strength to strength.
38:48.9
Or when you're weak,
38:51.7
there's absolutely no surprise
38:53.5
that Digong will come out
38:54.6
and suddenly say this
38:55.8
about the chacha.
38:56.9
That this is a breath of fresh air.
39:01.0
so ito yung base dun sa isang,
39:03.8
oh, kasi yung administration
39:08.0
nag-welcome na sila.
39:09.8
Yeah, so I'm just trying to find
39:14.4
Bakit hindi yung quote
39:15.2
ni Digong nandito?
39:18.0
I'm just trying to find.
39:19.0
But from what I saw
39:21.3
si Digong said something like,
39:23.1
ang concern lang naman niya
39:25.4
is yung sa presidential term limits
39:27.6
Because as far as he's concerned,
39:28.8
at least he followed that.
39:29.8
Although we know naman
39:30.3
the context for that,
39:32.5
Pumalpak lang kasing
39:33.3
gusto niyang Medvedev-Putin
39:37.6
at least in his case,
39:38.2
so suddenly he's being
39:43.4
palitan yung constitution
39:44.4
na wag lang galawin
39:47.0
Kasi that will trigger,
39:49.0
medyo trigger warning yan,
39:50.7
That will trigger panic,
39:51.8
especially if you're president.
39:54.0
Your president is,
39:57.3
Ferdinand Marcos Jr.
39:58.8
Digong essentially did two
40:07.6
ay hindi ko tinawag
40:08.4
na drug addict si,
40:10.9
wala akong sinabi na ganoon na,
40:12.1
even if you kill me
40:12.9
a thousand times,
40:13.9
wala akong sinabing ganoon.
40:15.6
I did not say that.
40:16.7
Even if you kill me
40:17.4
a thousand times,
40:18.1
you not say such a thing.
40:19.3
Make it taking a drug.
40:20.7
Pero kung sabihin mong addict,
40:22.4
wala akong sinabing ganyan.
40:24.4
Patayin ako ni Marcos niyan,
40:26.5
maawa ka naman sa akin,
40:34.0
itag na natin doon sa video
40:35.4
kung saan sabihin niya,
40:36.9
nagmura-mura siya na,
40:38.8
na meron tayong drug addict.
40:43.4
He says something
40:44.1
and he totally contradicts it
40:45.5
and he's okay with that
40:46.6
as if nothing happened.
40:47.9
We see this with Donald Trump,
40:49.3
we see this with Bolsonaro,
40:50.6
we see this with Orban.
40:52.8
We'd see this even
40:53.7
with Vladimir Putin.
40:55.4
Yung ganyan na paiba-ibang
40:60.0
change of tone din siya dito sa
41:03.7
essentially with BBM,
41:06.7
also withdrawing his
41:07.8
direct attack against
41:09.3
some sort of charter change,
41:11.7
I think the road is
41:12.8
very much paved na
41:15.9
and the administration
41:17.0
to push things forward.
41:19.1
that's why this is something
41:22.9
really discuss it.
41:26.0
ito yung sinabi ni
41:30.8
we can have the plebiscite
41:31.8
in the local elections
41:32.7
to be held in May next year,
41:35.9
that will be a huge deal
41:37.4
that will save us so much.
41:38.7
So that's why we're studying it
41:39.9
in terms of logistics.
41:41.6
Kasi kung sinabay mo ito,
41:44.2
Sinabay mo itong plebiscite
41:45.6
sa new constitution,
41:49.3
pipili ka kung sino
41:50.2
mga gusto mong senador,
41:51.4
Meron din isa pang form.
41:53.4
sa constitutional amendment,
41:55.0
blah, blah, blah.
42:00.0
okay lang palitan
42:00.9
yung economic provisions?
42:02.3
The final versions,
42:03.8
I think it's still,
42:04.7
still somehow in the works.
42:06.7
But it will go through
42:07.8
some sort of plebiscite.
42:10.3
the administration
42:15.8
ang kinu-quote ko dito.
42:19.2
Richard H. Dargan.
42:20.6
Ito yung sinabi ko
42:21.2
sa Time Magazine.
42:21.9
So this is the article
42:22.6
by Time Magazine.
42:24.6
one concern will be,
42:26.9
in Time Magazine,
42:27.5
dito sa article na yan,
42:32.1
itong constitutional change.
42:36.8
ako kasi personally,
42:40.6
na pag pinalitan mo
42:41.5
yung constitution,
42:42.8
maging magandang bansa natin
42:44.0
in terms of investments
42:45.5
I think that's just blah-blah.
42:47.1
I think that's just
42:49.1
Because if you look at Vietnam,
42:50.4
you look at China,
42:51.4
you look at many countries
42:52.3
with very restrictive
42:54.0
and investment rules,
42:56.0
nakukuha nyo lang investment.
42:58.1
because investors
42:58.8
look at things like
42:59.9
cost of logistics,
43:02.5
proper infrastructure,
43:05.0
They're looking at things
43:08.6
They're looking at things
43:09.3
like political stability.
43:10.7
They're looking at things
43:11.3
like human capital,
43:12.5
production costs,
43:14.0
productivity trends.
43:15.3
Yun yung mga ganyan
43:16.0
ang tinitignan ng mga,
43:17.2
yun ang mga tinitignan
43:19.4
when they come to a country.
43:20.7
So, yung mga nagsabi na
43:23.5
certain provisions
43:24.8
of our constitutions,
43:25.6
then we're gonna be
43:26.2
super progressive.
43:27.2
I don't know what they're talking about.
43:28.5
I don't think that these people
43:29.4
understand basic development
43:30.5
economics or have done
43:31.5
a basic comparative analysis.
43:34.6
ginagamit lang ito
43:36.9
to push for some sort of
43:38.4
change in the constitution.
43:41.1
mukhang the agreement is
43:42.5
there'll be some sort of
43:44.8
coordinated voting
43:54.3
ng anong mga provisions
43:57.8
at anong pupunta dyan
43:59.3
sa plebiscite next year.
44:03.0
while there is an agreement
44:04.1
on changing certain provisions
44:06.8
of the constitution
44:07.6
when it comes to the economic
44:08.9
aspect of our constitution,
44:12.5
I doubt that this is really
44:13.6
the ultimate purpose.
44:16.4
And I doubt that this will be
44:17.4
the ultimate thing.
44:18.9
But having said that,
44:21.3
yung plebiscite next year
44:22.7
will just be about
44:23.9
the economic provisions,
44:26.9
papalitan yung economic provisions
44:29.8
the moment na mag-clear
44:30.7
ito sa plebiscite,
44:32.1
you're gonna set a precedence.
44:34.0
You're kinda normalizing
44:35.4
opening a can of worms.
44:37.4
Kasi the moment na maging
44:39.1
na palitan yung ating
44:41.2
the next thing you know,
44:42.5
they're gonna be another plebiscite
44:43.8
about another provisions, right?
44:45.5
Or if BBM will not succeed
44:47.7
the next administration
44:48.6
will push for that.
44:55.8
it's a psychological barrier
44:57.8
but also it's about
44:58.7
clearing a political barrier.
45:00.7
It's a kind of an uncharted
45:03.9
So yun ang tinitignan natin.
45:05.3
block ko lang ito,
45:06.0
mawalang yan ito.
45:07.4
wag kang bastos ah.
45:08.6
O yan, block ka na.
45:12.5
Ayan, bastos kayo dyan.
45:17.7
Umayos kayo dito.
45:24.1
Okay, tanggal ka na.
45:26.7
Ayan, umayos kayo dyan.
45:30.4
ma-improve yung utak nyo sa buhay,
45:32.3
medyo tumaas-taas
45:33.7
ang pag-intindihan sa buhay,
45:35.8
di wag na kayo bumunta dito.
45:37.7
Ganon kasimple lang naman eh.
45:38.9
Ganon kasimple lang naman.
45:40.0
Wag kayong manggulog
45:40.8
dito sa classroom natin,
45:42.5
We're having a proper discussion here.
45:44.0
So, what I'm saying is this.
45:46.2
If the Senate and Congress
45:47.9
even to the minimum
45:49.8
economic provisions,
45:52.2
you're already setting
45:54.9
You're already setting a precedence.
45:58.8
bago matapos ang taon
46:04.2
ang 2025 elections,
46:09.4
comprehensive constitutional change.
46:12.0
constitution altogether.
46:13.2
Charter change meaning.
46:15.5
But even if that doesn't happen,
46:17.1
you're already setting
46:18.9
and you're potentially
46:19.7
opening kind of forms here.
46:21.5
Because you're normalizing
46:24.9
with the constitution
46:27.2
So, having said that,
46:28.3
kaya nga sabi ko eh,
46:30.6
you can say in a way
46:31.4
it's a slippery slope.
46:33.6
kind of forms there.
46:47.0
The idea of changing
46:51.8
the moment na you do that,
46:53.3
gusto mga maging diktador.
46:55.0
ang mga Marcos-style dictatorship.
47:01.3
controversy and backlash,
47:05.0
dun sa ating saligang batas,
47:07.0
setting a precedence.
47:11.4
May benefit Marcos
47:11.9
ahead of 2020 elections
47:15.1
at the very least,
47:17.2
the next president
47:18.7
or the next generation
47:19.5
to push for something else.
47:21.4
madali lang sabihin
47:22.0
ng next president na,
47:25.3
sa dating presidente,
47:30.6
lang sa saligang batas.
47:32.5
kulang yan, guys,
47:33.7
para mas marami pa tayong
47:36.1
mas marami pa tayong
47:37.5
mas marami pa tayong
47:38.6
Kailangan pa natin
47:39.4
palitan yung mga ganyan.
47:43.5
Kaya nga parati ko sinasabi
47:44.5
na mahalaga na talaga
47:49.0
mobilize ang opposition.
47:51.1
nagpa-popcorn-popcorn
47:53.4
things are already moving.
48:00.2
constitutional change.
48:04.7
partial lang yan,
48:06.5
you never know, eh,
48:11.1
malakas pa si BBM,
48:12.1
he'll push even for more.
48:13.5
Or if after 2025,
48:15.3
kung hindi pa malakas
48:16.7
yung next na president
48:17.6
can push for more
48:18.4
comprehensive charter change.
48:21.9
overseeing a change
48:23.3
that try to avoid
48:24.6
something that his
48:26.5
the moment we'll go there,
48:28.3
then you're talking about
48:29.1
some new uncharted territories.
48:31.5
at the very least,
48:32.9
certain psychological barriers.
48:35.0
You're breaking stigma.
48:36.7
You're breaking taboos.
48:38.6
Pag nawala na yung
48:39.7
tabo and stigma na yan,
48:41.1
it's an open field.
48:45.3
very, very close attention
48:46.6
to what is happening here.
48:48.3
Ako, ang basa ko talaga dito is,
48:50.5
kung hindi nag-ingay ng tao,
48:52.0
kung hindi nagkaroon ng backlash
48:53.1
dun sa EDSA puwera,
48:56.3
ibang usapan na ngayon, eh.
48:57.6
Hindi lang plebiscite
48:59.7
economic provisions.
49:01.2
This could have gone
49:01.9
in a completely different direction.
49:04.0
Mas wilder version.
49:05.7
So, what I'm saying here
49:07.6
hindi ibig sabihin yan
49:12.4
Hindi ibig sabihin yan
49:13.7
hopeless case tayo.
49:15.7
Ang ibig sabihin niya
49:16.7
is dapat vigilant tayo.
49:18.5
Dapat engaged tayo.
49:19.9
Dapat nagsuscrutinize tayo.
49:21.8
And having said all of that,
49:23.2
ako, in principle,
49:25.6
with changing certain
49:27.7
provisions of our Constitution
49:29.5
dahil I'm not 100% sold
49:32.4
on the 1987 Constitution.
49:34.3
I think there are a lot of things
49:35.5
in the 1987 Constitution
49:36.8
that hindi necessarily tugma
49:39.0
dun sa mga pangangailangan natin
49:41.1
Sa aking palagay,
49:43.8
sa 1997 Constitution
49:45.0
na more of reaction
49:46.5
dun sa mga masamang nangyari
49:48.6
nung panahon ng martial law
49:49.8
but they're not necessarily
49:51.5
the best thing for us
49:53.0
given anong pangangailangan
49:55.7
sa panahon ngayon.
49:59.5
But having said that,
50:00.9
the change should be done
50:02.9
and the change should be done
50:04.4
by the right people.
50:06.6
the least we can do is
50:10.3
And if we find something
50:12.6
dapat mag-react tayo,
50:13.6
mag-respond tayo.
50:15.0
Because ang trajectory ngayon
50:17.4
is not too different
50:18.7
from Maharlika Fund.
50:20.2
Kung mahala rin yung
50:22.0
the first version
50:23.7
was kind of crazy.
50:25.6
In fact, the first version
50:26.5
I think had Marcos Jr.
50:28.9
head of the Maharlika Fund.
50:30.6
And then nung nagkaroon
50:31.4
ng sobrang daming
50:33.5
they went through
50:34.3
multiple, multiple,
50:35.7
multiple provisions,
50:38.5
pinilit pa rin nila eh.
50:40.3
cleared the Maharlika Fund.
50:41.3
But the Maharlika Fund
50:43.8
the final version
50:45.5
or the final version
50:46.7
that is still being
50:47.5
operationalized and all,
50:48.8
it's nowhere as bad
50:49.8
as the first version.
50:52.0
hindi nag-succeed
50:54.1
in terms of stopping
50:55.2
the Maharlika Fund
50:57.0
they at least were able
51:01.7
hindi lang call out
51:04.4
the worst version
51:05.9
of the Maharlika Fund.
51:10.0
is going to happen
51:10.8
through scrutiny mobilization,
51:13.3
that the opposition can do
51:14.7
the worst version
51:16.0
of chacha doesn't happen.
51:17.9
And you want to also do that
51:19.0
because you want to also
51:20.3
to the next administrations
51:21.8
or to this administration
51:24.2
na hindi natutulog
51:26.8
Na bantay-saradong
51:30.5
and people will make sure
51:33.5
for the good of the country
51:34.5
hindi for the good
51:37.6
thank you very much again.
51:38.6
Pasensya again guys
51:40.0
kung may mga audio problem
51:41.2
or technical problems
51:43.2
it's the phone or something
51:44.5
so probably I have to get
51:46.4
And thank you sa mga suggestions
51:48.5
wag mo na yung mga Chinese phone
51:49.6
baka Korean na lang.
51:52.7
And thank you also dun
51:53.8
sa mga pasensyoso
51:57.4
na-appreciate nila
51:58.3
what we're trying to do here
51:59.2
in this kind of a monologue
52:00.2
conversation and all of that.
52:04.9
these vlogs are not
52:07.6
These vlogs are not
52:11.8
These vlogs are also
52:12.7
about making sure
52:15.9
our critical thinking skills.
52:19.1
Kasi hindi naman pwede
52:20.0
na purong criticize ka lang.
52:21.8
Dapat meron ka rin
52:24.4
dapat may framework ka.
52:26.2
Dapat you criticize
52:27.2
even the criticism
52:28.0
if it's necessary.
52:29.8
And at the same time,
52:31.3
ng 360 degrees yan.
52:33.2
Sino yung mga actors involved?
52:35.2
ng mga actors na yan?
52:36.3
How are they positioned
52:37.1
towards each other?
52:38.3
Ano yung asymmetry of power?
52:39.4
Ano yung power relationship?
52:41.1
Anong pwede natin gawin?
52:43.3
first, thinking straight.
52:46.0
understanding of the situation.
52:47.1
And second is about
52:49.7
we can scrutinize
52:50.7
and push the government
52:51.5
in the right direction.
52:54.5
the role of the citizen
52:55.3
is to hold the feet of trapos
52:57.1
close to the fire
52:58.0
so that they behave themselves
52:59.1
just in case they want
52:59.8
to do something fishy.
53:02.5
thank you very much.
53:03.5
And marami salamat, guys.
53:05.3
with you guys soon.
53:06.6
We'll try to hope
53:07.5
we'll try to also
53:08.8
have more discussions
53:09.6
with other guests soon.
53:12.8
medyo pagod na tayo.
53:13.6
Habang nungusapan namin
53:14.7
ni Ronaldo kahapon,
53:15.8
umabot ng tatlong oras almost.
53:17.3
So, mag-recover muna tayo dyan.
53:20.6
hindi jet lag yung audio natin
53:22.3
katulad nung kahapon.
53:27.1
God bless and talk to you soon.
53:33.6
Thank you very much.
